Skip to Content

In the News

Pennsylvania state icon

U.S. House assassination committee, with Houlahan agreeing, issues report

Originally published by The Daily Local.

The assassination attempt against former President Donald Trump at a Pennsylvania rally in July was “preventable and should not have happened,” according to a bipartisan House panel that is investigating the shooting and what it calls the “stunning security failures” at the event.

The report from a House task force, released Monday, is just the latest look at the cascading and wide-ranging law enforcement failings that preceded the July 13 shooting at the Butler, Pennsylvania, rally where Trump was struck in the ear by gunfire. One rallygoer was killed in the shooting and two others were wounded.

The committee’s membership includes U.S. Rep. Chrissy Houlahan, D-6th, of Easttown, whose district includes Chester County and southern Berks County. She is a former U.S. Air Force Officer and engineer.

On Monday, Houlahan commented on the preliminary report.

“Today’s interim report from our bipartisan task force confirms what we’ve been thinking: the assassination attempt on former President Trump could’ve been prevented,” said Houlahan. “To hear that there was no joint meeting or command posts between the Secret Service, state, and local law enforcement on the day of the rally is unfathomable. With a background in operations, I know how weak lines of communication can destroy systems as they did to our security systems on that day. I look forward to the final report and being able to prevent something like this from ever happening again.”

Houlahan, a former U.S. Air Force officer, had gone to visit the scene of the deadly attempt with other from the committee in August. Here is what she wrote at the time.

“My community wants to make sure that we can work together, that we can work together to get the answers that we deserve,” she said in a statement. “Because there is no time when political violence is acceptable. And it certainly is not acceptable that anybody who’s a candidate or seeking elected office should be vulnerable in this way, and that the people who are gathered to hear them and their opinions should be vulnerable in this way, too.

“By my background, I am a military officer, but also an engineer and an operator,” she added. “I spent most of my life in operations and so what I’m going to be spending my time on is trying to understand what happened in terms of procedures and protocols to make sure that we understand that and specifically also will be focusing on some new technologies such as the drone that was involved in this particular situation.”

Members of both the House and Senate have repeatedly questioned why the Secret Service, an agency tasked with protecting the country’s top leaders, didn’t do a better job communicating with local authorities during the campaign rally, particularly when it came to securing the building that was widely agreed to be a security threat but that ultimately was left so unprotected that gunman Thomas Matthew Crooks was able to climb up and shoot.

Lawmakers in their report focus on “the fragmented lines of communication and unclear chains of command” between Secret Service and Pennsylvania state and local police but place the majority of the blame on the Secret Service for the security breakdown.

“Federal, state, and local law enforcement officers could have engaged Thomas Matthew Crooks at several pivotal moments,” the report stated. Lawmakers added that throughout the afternoon, “as Crooks’s behavior became increasingly suspicious, fragmented lines of communication allowed Crooks to evade law enforcement” and climb onto the unsecured roof where he would eventually open fire.

“Put simply, the evidence obtained by the Task Force to date shows the tragic and shocking events of July 13 were preventable and should not have happened,” the report continued.

The preliminary findings are drawn from thousands of pages of documents, nearly two dozen transcribed interviews with state and local officials as well as a series of both classified and non-classified briefings from senior officials at the Secret Service and the FBI.

The report breaks little new ground, as the failed Secret Service response has been already documented by an independent commission, an interim Senate report as well as congressional testimony and news media investigations. The House report, like others before it, does not identify specific individuals who may be to blame.

But The Associated Press has previously reported that at least five Secret Service agents have been placed on modified duty. The director of the Secret Service at the time, Kimberly Cheatle, resigned shortly after the attempt, saying she took full responsibility for the lapse.

The task force — comprised of seven Republicans and six Democrats — showcased some of the report’s findings during a public hearing last month. Lawmakers say they plan to issue a final report, including recommendations to avoid future assassination attempts against political candidates, by mid-December.

The task force has also begun investigating the second assassination attempt on Trump last month where a man with a rifle camped outside one of his golf courses in southern Florida.